RANKING

Neil Young’s greatest albums ranked and reviewed! 1968-1975

SOURCES


— ‘We had a lotta fun making that record… It was beautiful.’ Page 293-295, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ‘We got tones nobody’s… enthused. Page 293-295, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ’Neil hires some of the best musicians… nobody but Neil does.’ Page 361-366, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— Neil Young got the call about… carry with him to the grave.’ Page 387-392, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— Rehearsals for the… events in Danny Whitten's life. Page 387-392, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ‘I think it’s the worst record I ever made… a great record.’ Page 365, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ‘It was a perfect situation for good… Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream*. Page 382, Young, Neil, ‘Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream’, (Penguin, 2013)

— He and Crazy Horse… a Nazi uniform. Page 486-488, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003); Page 383-384, Young, Neil, ‘Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream’, (Penguin, 2013)

— I was getting past the lost relationship… a grip on something.’ Page 383-384, Young, Neil, ‘Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream’, (Penguin, 2013)

— Shannon Forbes recalls… were actually inspired by the screenplay. Page 332, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— Young biographer Jimmy McDonough…without overdubbed vocals and the first to feature a 17-year-old Nils Lofgren. Page 332, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— Over the course of several days…handful of sessions between January and March 1969. Page 297-299, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ‘That whole album was like catching the group… until we heard the album.’ Page 298, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— ‘Every musician has one guy on the planet… guy was Danny Whitten.’ Page 398, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— The recording sessions for…screwed up that we could easily just fall on our faces. … We were wide open … just wide open ….’. Page, 411, 413, 431-432, 738, McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

— The penultimate song… being ‘underwater without bubbles’. Page 204, Young, Neil, ‘Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream’ (Viking 2012)

BIBLIOGRAPHY


McDonough, Jimmy, ‘Shakey: Neil Young's Biography’ (Vintage, 2003)

Young, Neil, ‘Waging Heavy Peace: A Hippie Dream’ (Viking 2012)

TOP TAGS

MORE ON THE 1960s



RANKING

By David Rea

28 February 2026

MAKING A MASTERPIECE

18 October 2025

ESSAY

By David Rea

28 February 2026