ALBUM REVIEW REWIND

Liam Gallagher John Squire

One year after they collaborated, their album has largely been forgotten. So was it any good? Revisit our original review.

7

By David Rea

1st September, 2025

First published: 1st March, 2024

LABEL: Warner Music UK RELEASE DATE: 1st March, 2024

IN THE RUBBLE AND ASH of the Stone Roses’ 1990s demise, John Squire and Ian Brown separately produced thirty-five songs in less than three years. It was a solid work rate by anyone’s standards, but compared to the meagre two studio albums the Roses had managed in the previous decade and a half, it was a creative torrent. The relative inundation of new material hinted that considerable artistic frustration had built up during the interminable production of the Stone Roses’ sophomore album, The Second Coming. The titles of the former band-mates’ first new records only compounded the sense that valuable time had been wasted – The Seahorses’ Do It Yourself and Ian Brown's Unfinished Monkey Business appearing to express exasperation over their unproductive creative partnership. Not content with just having a swipe with his album title, John Squire went further, writing one or two lyrics apparently aimed at Brown and his former Stone Roses bandmates, including the Seahorses’ ‘Blinded by the Sun’: ‘you're wasting your time and my time as well’. Coincidence or not, even the word ‘seahorses’ turned out to be an anagram for 'he hates roses’.

Following the Stone Roses’ second collapse in the late 2010s, and another creative failure to produce a new album together, John Squire seemed to be at it again on the first teaser track for his new 2024 album with Liam Gallagher. As YouTuber James Hargreaves has pointed out the record’s title track, ‘Just Another Rainbow’ looked to be another resentful anagram, which unscrambled spelled out: ‘to hear Ian Brown’. (Try reading the lyrics with the phrase decoded and it quickly becomes an extended diatribe against his former bandmate.) Musically on first listen ‘Just Another Rainbow’ also sounded like slightly dull mid-tempo psychedelic rock, which cried out for Ian Brown's pop sensibility to lift it. There was a very real sense that the new album would be laced with oblique jibes at Brown, and all the worse for his absence in the music.

Tracklist

1. Raise Your Hands

2. Mars To Liverpool

3. One Day At A Time

4. I’m a Wheel

5. Just Another Rainbow

6. Love You Forever

7. Make It Up As You Go Along

8. You're Not The Only One

9. I’m So Bored

10. Mother Nature's Song

“The album cover’s gaudy pop art collage of everyday shopping items, from chocolate bars to an AA battery, captures the throwaway levity of much of the album’s lyrics. ‘You should have fucked me when you had the chance’, Liam Gallagher sings on One Day at a Time, sounding like someone making a quip between gassy, beer burps.”

Liam Gallagher John Squire, however, is very much in one of Britpop's key registers: cocksure optimism. Almost front to back it is tuneful, guitar-driven pop-rock, which wouldn't have sounded out of place in 1995. The album derives at least some of its power from nostalgia for that golden age, and the masterstroke of enlisting Britpop’s Lad King Liam Gallagher for vocal duties capitalised on it. The album cover’s gaudy pop art collage of everyday shopping items, from chocolate bars to an AA battery, captures the throwaway levity of much of the album’s lyrics. ‘You should have fucked me when you had the chance’, Liam Gallagher sings on ‘One Day at a Time’, sounding like someone making a quip between gassy beer burps.

In person Squire is probably the least expressive man in pop: he hasn’t moved a facial muscle since the eighties and his speaking voice has remained a staggeringly inexpressive murmur throughout the intervening decades. Yet he has still always somehow managed to create a forcefield of Manchester boy cool around him, producing jangle pop riffs as good as any written by the Byrds and blues licks Jimmy Page would have been proud of. Squire festooned the Stone Roses’ legendary debut album with melodic guitar solos, which were as hummable as the vocal melodies. But here the everywhere-all-at-once guitar work is heavier and rawer. There might be relatively little providing the sugar rush of the Seahorses’ ‘Love is the Law’ riff, or any solos as achingly perfect as those on the Stone Roses' debut, but it adds plenty of texture and mood.

One of the few detours from the Britpop aesthetic is the partial blues of ‘I'm a Wheel’, which sounds as sparse and raw as John Lennon's ‘Yer Blues’. Then, almost as if the song cannot deliver on its premise, it morphs into a melodic refrain of a piece with the rest of the album. Alongside the progressive folk suggested in the opening bars of ‘One Day at a Time’, it feels like a missed opportunity to broaden the album’s musical palette. There are one or two other near misses. It takes a rare talent to turn middle-age ennui or contentment into engaging art. Now in his 60s, John Squire doesn't quite manage it on ‘I’m So Bored’, a midlife whinge disguised as borderline punk rock. One of the album’s best tunes ‘Mother Nature's Song’ might reference the Beatles’ ‘Mother Nature’s Son’, but Liam Gallagher sounds like a middle-age man sitting in his garden with a nice cup of tea, enjoying a spot of clement weather.

When asked what the Stone Roses’ plans were when they reformed in 2011, Ian Brown answered with characteristic bombast: ‘Our plans are to take over the world’. It was a reminder of their entirely justifiable belief in their own extraordinary talent. True, this would have been a better album in the hands of the Roses, but then it probably wouldn't ever have been finished, had these songs been left to them. There would have been rumours and hearsay, blog post headlines and shaky iPhone footage on YouTube suggesting something was happening somewhere on the distant horizon – tantalising but ungraspable: just another rainbow. But those days of shit-show media rodeos promising another Stone Roses album are over. Instead, we have ten new John Squire songs; Squire’s and Gallagher’s conjoined silhouette against the dying sun of the 1990s – that guitar and that voice. It is more than enough to make you reach forward and turn the volume up.

© 2024 State of Sound. All Rights Reserved

MORE ON BRITPOP



ANNIVERSARY REVIEW REWIND

By David Rea

1st September, 2025

First published: 30th August, 2024